A 24-year-old woman is questioning her entire relationship after her boyfriend called police over her creative writing. She discovered his betrayal when officers arrived at her door for a surprise welfare check. The boyfriend called police because her horror novel chapter seemed “too real” to him.

This whole mess started three years ago when they met in a writing class. She’s been working on a dark fantasy trilogy since she was 16. Her writing actually makes money, unlike her boyfriend John who studied journalism but works elsewhere. The irony is thick here.

She asked John to beta read some chapters since her usual reader wasn’t available. The section featured her main character getting kidnapped and experimented on. She specifically warned him the content would be grotesque and horrifying. He claimed he could handle it.

The Moment Her Boyfriend Called Police Changed Everything

John didn’t just struggle with the dark content. He secretly contacted the local police department behind her back. His reasoning? The torture descriptions sounded too realistic and involved non-consensual experimentation. To be clear, this wasn’t sexual assault content – just fictional medical torture.

The worst part is how she found out. John never mentioned making the call. Instead, police officers knocked on her door the next morning for a welfare check. Imagine answering your door to cops because your own boyfriend reported you.

She had to explain the entire situation to confused officers. They searched her house anyway before finally apologizing for the mix-up. The humiliation must have been overwhelming. Her neighbors probably saw everything too.

When confronted, John offered weak excuses about the story getting in his head. He called it a mistake and expected her to just understand his concern. The audacity of asking her to drop it completely is mind-blowing.

Why This Goes Beyond a Simple Misunderstanding

Here’s what makes this situation so disturbing. She’s been publishing dark fiction for years. John has read her previous work before without incident. This chapter wasn’t even her darkest material according to her own assessment.

The timeline doesn’t add up either. If John was genuinely disturbed by the content, why did he stay over that night? He was reportedly cuddly and affectionate after reading material that supposedly worried him enough to call authorities.

Reddit users immediately spotted the red flags in this relationship drama. The top comment called it a deliberate setup rather than an honest mistake. Over 4,000 people agreed with that assessment.

Another commenter asked the crucial question: what did he hope to achieve? Calling police on your girlfriend’s creative writing serves no legitimate purpose. It only creates problems and embarrassment for her.

The Deeper Issues This Incident Reveals

This goes way beyond poor judgment or misunderstanding fictional content. John’s actions show a fundamental lack of respect for her work and privacy. He violated her trust by involving authorities without discussion.

The secrecy makes everything worse. If he genuinely feared for someone’s safety, why hide the call from her? His behavior suggests ulterior motives beyond simple concern.

Some possibilities include jealousy over her writing success, resentment about her income, or attempts to sabotage her work. Maybe he wanted to create drama or test her reaction. None of these motivations reflect well on him.

This reminds me of other relationship drama stories where partners deliberately undermine each other’s careers or hobbies. The pattern often escalates over time if not addressed immediately.

The woman is right to question whether this relationship can survive. Trust forms the foundation of healthy partnerships. John shattered that trust through deception and betrayal. His refusal to take full responsibility makes reconciliation even harder.

Moving forward requires honest conversation about boundaries and respect. If John can’t support her creative work, they’re fundamentally incompatible. Writers need partners who understand the difference between fiction and reality. This situation reveals John might not be that person.

From r/relationship_advice (2,182 upvotes)