Woman “Arrested” for Stealing Pomegranates Guy Thought We…
The Original Post
Obligatory this happened on Tuesday, and yes, itās exactly as stupid as it sounds.
So Iād been working all day, had soup on the stove, and realized I was out of pomegranates (which are basically the only food my anxiety lets me eat without a full blown panic attack). The grocery store is two streets away a simple five minute walk. Easy. In and out and back home to finally relax.
So I stop at the dollar store first to grab my grandfather a sudoku book and some chocolate. Then I head into FreshCo with two bags:
\- one dollar store bag (already paid for)
\- one empty green reusable bag for groceries
First thing I grab? Three pomegranates. Theyāre awkward to carry, so I toss them into the green bag and keep shopping.
I grab cherries which I balanced on my fingers, juice boxes, and a FreshCo gift card. I check out. I even buy a bag at checkout to put them all in.
What do I forget? Three pomegranates. The only thing in the green bag…
So I pay, grab my receipt, and start walking out, fully in go go go mode because my soup is sweating on my stove at home.
Right before the doors, a random guy dressed like a normal shopper steps in front of me and says:
āYou didnāt pay for those apples.ā
Immediately Iām like⦠what apples? I donāt buy apples. I donāt like apples. I donāt even think about damn apples.
So Iām like, āI didnāt buy apples. Leave me alone.ā
He insists. I insist. Then suddenly he goes:
āThatās it! Youāre under arrestā
Like excuse me? At this point, my brain still hasnāt connected āapplesā to āpomegranatesā because:
1. They are not apples.
2. I already paid
3. My brain is fried from the lack of sleep and stress from working all day.
Then he points at my bag and it finally clicks.
āOh shit. I forgot to pay for the pomegranates. Iāll just go back and pay.ā
āNope. Too late. You had intent to steal.ā
I had not left the store.
I had not passed the doors.
I was still in the little area before leaving the store.
Doesnāt matter now. Because Iām now a hardened criminal (I guess he got intimidated by the tattoos and black hair).
He escorts me to the back room, reads me my rights (which I later learned he legally should not have done), tells me Iām being charged with theft under $5,000, and says Iām going to jail.
Over. Three. Fucking. Pomegranates.
So there I am panicking. Straight into fight or flight (thank you anxiety). I start shaking, crying, I threw up on the floor, stuck trying to call my veteran grandfather who I look after who is waiting for me at home, while also thinking about my soup probably setting on fire at home.
They tell me the police are on the way. They are not. I sit there for four hours. FOUR FUCKING HOURS.
The store closes at 10pm Itās 9:30pm. Police finally call and tell the loss prevention guy theyāre not coming tonight and to just release me.
So they do. But not before trespassing me from the store for a year… Iāve been going to this store since I was 12 years old, where I shop multiple times a week, where the owner literally custom ordered items for me…
Now here’s the kicker folks!
So the guy thought they were apples, eh? Apples are $1 each and Pomegranates are $4.50 each (on sale for $2), so he thought I was stealing three apples worth $3…
TL/DR: Forgot to pay for three pomegranates, loss prevention guy thought they were apples, āarrestedā me, threatened jail, made me throw up, held me for four hours, and banned me from the store over $6 of fruit.
EDIT 1: This is not AI I was recording as it went down as I knew there is something wrong about them detaining me and reading my rights especially bringing me into a room with no cameras for 4 hours.
EDIT 2: For context I am 5 foot 2 inches and this guy was like 6 foot, I’m a 22 year old woman, and he looked to be a man in his mid 30s. I should’ve also mentioned that I am deaf and use hearing aids and at the time I was leaving the store I was listening to music and If you know about listening to music with hearing aids you can’t hear much other than music it’s not like earphones you have to disconnect them via the mobile app to hear anything outside.
What Reddit Said
Redditors were outraged by the loss prevention officer’s behavior. Many pointed out that he had no legal authority to read her rights or detain her for four hours. However, the top comment focused on a different concern entirely: leaving soup on the stove while going out.
Most users agreed the detention was excessive and likely illegal. They encouraged OP to research security guard limitations and potentially pursue legal action. In fact, several commenters noted that since she never left the store, there was no theft to begin with.
The Verdict
Reddit’s consensus was clear: OP was wrongfully treated. Being arrested for stealing pomegranates over a simple mistake crosses every line of reasonable loss prevention. This represents a classic case of workplace power abuse where security overstepped their authority. Moreover, the four-hour detention without police involvement likely violated multiple legal boundaries.
Original post from r/tifu (1,003 upvotes, 408 comments)