Dad Wants Daughter Back After Divorce – She Says No | Reddit
The Original Post
My mom died when I (16f) was a baby. My aunt (my momās sister) stepped in and became like a 2nd mom to me. When I was 8 she moved for work so I went from seeing her every day to her flying me out 1-2 times a month plus 1 week of winter break, spring break, and 50/50 over the summer.
When I was 12 my dad married Judy and they kept saying she was my new mom and I donāt need to keep visiting my aunt because I have Judy. He also gave my room to Judyās kids since it was bigger and I refused to share and told my aunt that they decided that I couldnāt fly alone so she either had to fly out to get me or drive all day there and back.
I decided to stay with my aunt a few months after my dad married Judy because it was pretty obvious that he cared about his new family more than me.
My dad and Judy are getting divorced now because Judy cheated on him and he found out that their new kids werenāt his. He called me and asked me to move back home because he misses me and he doesnāt have any family left. I said no because I like it here. My aunt is a way better parent than my dad was and sheās been dating this guy that comes over on weekends and makes us the best burgers and steaks and he fixes cars up as a hobby/side job so heās working on one for me. I also really like my school and I have friends here and were really close to a lot of good colleges so I probably wonāt even have to move out for college.
My dad and his side of the family are upset that I wonāt move back because heās my dad and he needs me but heās the one that chose his new family over me and them getting divorced isnāt my problem to solve. I donāt really plan to change my mind but I want to know if me refusing to move back makes me an asshole.
What Reddit Said
Redditors overwhelmingly supported the teen’s decision to stay with her aunt. Most commenters pointed out the obvious pattern: dad only reached out after his new family fell apart. They questioned whether he genuinely missed his daughter or just needed someone to fill the void.
However, many users also highlighted a crucial point about parental responsibility. They emphasized that children shouldn’t be expected to manage their parents’ emotions or loneliness. Moreover, commenters worried about what would happen if dad found another romantic partner.
The Verdict
The overwhelming consensus: OP is Not the Asshole (NTA). This situation perfectly illustrates how a dad wants daughter back after divorce only when convenient for him. Reddit recognized this as classic family conflict where the parent’s priorities were exposed. The teen deserves stability with her aunt rather than being treated as a backup plan for her father’s parental issues.
Original post from r/AmItheAsshole (7,678 upvotes, 516 comments)