RedditStories
AITA Stories

Mom Forces Whole Family on Diet – Husband & Son Revolt

📅 January 22, 2026 👁️ 22 views ⏱️ 4 min read
A mother put her entire family on the same diet plan as her 300-pound teenage daughter who gained weight from bullying and stress eating. Her husband and 17-year-old son are furious, claiming they’re being punished for the daughter’s weight problem and demanding separate meals.

The Original Post

I (F52) live with my husband (M55) and our two kids: daughter (F15) and son (M17).

My daughter has always been on the chubbier side, and honestly, our whole family is overweight. However, since she started high school, her weight gain became extreme. In the span of just a few months, she went from being somewhat chubby to weighing over 300 pounds at only 15 years old.

Obviously, this worried us a lot. We later realized the weight gain was a symptom of deeper issues. High school has been very hard for her, and she was being bullied. She started stress eating, and since we all gain weight easily, things escalated quickly. We are addressing the emotional side of this with a therapist and working with the school, but we also can’t ignore the physical weight gain.

I took her to a nutritionist, who gave her a structured meal plan to help her lose weight in a healthy way. She started the plan last week. I decided that our entire family would follow the same meal plan.

Here’s why:

1. I’m not cooking two separate meals every day. It’s much easier and more realistic for me to cook one meal for everyone.
2. We are all overweight. None of us are in as alarming a situation as my daughter, but losing some weight would benefit everyone.
3. I think it will be much easier for my daughter to stick to the plan if she’s not watching the rest of us eat differently or keep junk food in the house.
4. I honestly don’t see a downside to our family learning how to eat healthier together.

To be clear, I’m not starving anyone. I adjust portion sizes based on each person’s needs.

My husband and son are upset. They feel it’s unfair that just because my daughter gained a lot of weight, everyone has to “go on a diet.” They say I’m punishing them for her problem and that I should just cook separate meals, one for my daughter (and me, if I want) and one for them.

I don’t think I’m being unreasonable, but they’re acting like I am.

So, AITA?

EDIT: Okay, I get it, point taken about the word *“*diet.” I’m on the older side, and that’s just what we’ve always called intentional changes in eating. I genuinely appreciate the feedback, and if changing my language helps my family accept this better, I’m happy to do that. That said, I’d appreciate judgments focusing on my actions rather than getting stuck on word choice.

What Reddit Said

Reddit overwhelmingly supported the mother’s decision. Most users focused on her practical reasoning about cooking one meal for the family. However, they were particularly unsympathetic to the complaints from her husband and son.

The top comments emphasized that both the husband and teenage son are capable of cooking for themselves if they’re unhappy. Moreover, Redditors pointed out that the entire family being overweight makes this a reasonable health decision for everyone involved.

The Verdict

The overwhelming consensus: OP is Not the Asshole (NTA). This family diet weight loss conflict resonated with readers who saw it as practical parenting rather than punishment. Reddit agreed that supporting the daughter’s health journey while benefiting the whole family’s wellness was the right choice. This is a classic case of family conflict where reasonable boundaries met unreasonable resistance.


Original post from r/AmItheAsshole (4,048 upvotes, 744 comments)