Family Drama

Friend Asked for Threesome, Then Karma Struck HARD

📅 November 30, 2025 👁️ 16 views ⏱️ 6 min read

Picture this: your partner’s best friend calls asking for a threesome, gets nasty when rejected, then two weeks later discovers her boyfriend has been secretly hooking up with random men from Craigslist. If that sounds like a soap opera plot, buckle up – because this wild tale from Reddit proves that reality is stranger than fiction.

A bewildered fiancé recently took to r/TrueOffMyChest to share what might be the most jaw-dropping example of instant karma the internet has seen in a while. And honestly? The sheer audacity of some people will leave you speechless.

It all started with an unexpected phone call. The friend – let’s call her Sarah – rang up our storyteller’s fiancée with a very specific question. But first, she needed to make sure he wasn’t around to hear the conversation.

Red flag number one, anyone?

Once Sarah confirmed the coast was clear, the fiancée put the phone on speaker (smart move), and what came next was absolutely wild. Sarah casually asked if the couple would be interested in a foursome situation with her and her boyfriend.

Now, there’s nothing inherently wrong with consenting adults discussing these things, but the way this went down? Yikes.

The fiancée politely declined, explaining she wasn’t comfortable with her body in that kind of situation. It was a perfectly reasonable, respectful response that should have been the end of the conversation.

But wait – it gets worse.

Instead of gracefully accepting the “no,” Sarah got upset. She became rude and hung up on her supposed best friend. Because apparently, when you ask someone to participate in your sexual fantasies and they decline, the appropriate response is to throw a tantrum like a toddler who’s been denied candy.

The couple sat there staring at each other, probably wondering if they’d just entered an alternate dimension where basic human decency doesn’t exist.

But here’s where the story takes a delicious turn toward cosmic justice.

Two weeks later – two weeks – Sarah called back. This time, she wasn’t making inappropriate requests. She was sobbing.

Plot twist: she’d discovered her boyfriend cheating. And not just any kind of cheating – he’d been arranging secret meetups with random men on Craigslist for oral encounters.

The irony is so thick you could cut it with a knife.

This is the same guy who apparently came up with the brilliant idea to proposition his girlfriend’s best friend for group activities. The same guy who was supposedly so committed to his relationship that he wanted to “spice things up” with other people.

Turns out, he was already spicing things up – just not with his girlfriend’s knowledge or consent.

But here’s where the story gets even more bizarre: this isn’t an isolated incident. Our Reddit storyteller mentions that another friend of his fiancée caught her boyfriend doing the exact same thing – secret Craigslist hookups with men.

At this point, you have to wonder: is there some kind of epidemic we don’t know about?

The original poster’s bewildered commentary throughout the story is honestly the best part. He keeps circling back to the same incredulous question: “Am I the only man not meeting other guys on Craigslist behind my girlfriend’s back?”

And honestly? His confusion is completely valid. The mental gymnastics required to simultaneously proposition your girlfriend’s friends and secretly cheat with strangers is Olympic-level hypocrisy.

Reddit users were quick to pick up on the storyteller’s repetitive phrasing, with one commenter noting he managed to work variations of “sucking dick off random men from Craigslist” into his post seven different times. Sometimes when you’re processing something this absurd, you just have to keep saying it until it makes sense.

Spoiler alert: it never makes sense.

What really gets me about this situation is Sarah’s reaction to being turned down. She had the audacity to get upset with her friend for setting a boundary, but apparently never questioned why her boyfriend was so eager to involve other people in their relationship.

Maybe – and hear me out here – if your partner is pushing hard for group activities with your friends, it might be worth examining their motivations. Just a thought.

The karma in this story is so perfectly timed it almost feels scripted. Sarah pressures her friend into a sexual situation, gets nasty when rejected, then discovers her boyfriend has been living a double life.

Meanwhile, the couple who maintained their boundaries and treated each other with respect? They’re doing just fine, thank you very much.

There’s something deeply satisfying about seeing someone who tried to pressure others into compromising their values get a reality check about their own relationship. It’s like the universe said, “You want to judge other people’s choices? Let’s take a look at your own situation first.”

But beyond the schadenfreude, this story raises some serious questions about friendship, boundaries, and respect. What kind of friend puts you in an uncomfortable position and then gets angry when you don’t comply?

That’s not friendship – that’s manipulation.

The fiancée in this story handled everything perfectly. She was honest about her comfort level, didn’t judge her friend’s request, but also didn’t compromise her own values. And when her friend needed support later, she was still there to listen.

That’s what actual loyalty looks like.

This wild tale leaves us with some pretty important questions: How well do we really know the people in our lives? When someone pressures you to cross your boundaries, what does that say about their character? And most importantly – why do some people think their sexual desires should override everyone else’s comfort levels?

What would you have done in this situation? Would you have maintained the friendship after such disrespectful behavior? And how do you even process discovering that not one, but two people in your social circle are living completely double lives?

Share your thoughts – because honestly, we’re all still trying to figure out what just happened here.