Picture this: You’ve been recommending your favorite show to your partner for years, only to have them completely dismiss it. Then one day, another man mentions the exact same show, and suddenly your partner is ready to binge-watch immediately. Buckle up, because this story will have you questioning everything about relationship dynamics.

A woman took to Reddit’s infamous r/AmItheAsshole forum with what she initially called a “petty” situation. But honey, after reading her story, I’m convinced this is anything BUT petty – it’s a masterclass in frustration that’ll make your blood boil.

Our protagonist had been singing the praises of Gilmore Girls to her husband since they started dating. We’re talking years of recommendations here, people. She even went the extra mile, showing him clips to give him a taste of what he was missing.

His response? A hard pass. Every. Single. Time.

Now, she handled this rejection like a champ. She understood that not everyone vibes with the fast-talking mother-daughter duo from Stars Hollow, and that’s totally fair. So she did what any reasonable person would do – she rewatched the entire series twice by herself during their relationship.

But wait for it – the plot twist that’ll make you want to throw your phone across the room is coming.

Fast forward to a family dinner where her husband’s extended family gathered, including a cousin he’s particularly close to. Everything seemed normal, just your typical family get-together. Nothing could have prepared her for what happened next.

The very next day, as they’re settling in for some TV time, her husband casually opens Netflix and – I kid you not – searches up Gilmore Girls with the confidence of someone who’d just discovered fire.

His explanation? His cousin had mentioned that his wife got him “hooked” on the show, and now it’s become his “guilty pleasure.” The audacity of this moment is truly something to behold.

Our poor woman initially thought he was joking. Because surely, surely, this couldn’t be real life, right? But when she pointed out that she’d recommended this exact show countless times, his response was the cherry on top of this frustration sundae.

“Are you sure this is the same show?” he asked.

I’m sorry, WHAT? The same show she’d been talking about for years? The same clips she’d shown him? The same series she’d watched twice in front of him? That show?

Here’s where our heroine reaches her breaking point, and honestly, I’m here for it. She told him he could watch Gilmore Girls by himself since her recommendations had never been “good enough,” but his cousin’s word was apparently “gospel.”

Then she did what many of us would do – she went to their room to cool off. The kicker? She could hear him start the show for about a minute before switching to something else. Even he knew he’d messed up.

But let’s talk about why this situation is so much more than just a disagreement about TV shows. This is about respect, validation, and the infuriating pattern many women experience where their opinions carry less weight than identical opinions from men.

The Reddit community was not having it. The top comment, with over 3,000 upvotes, called out the “incredible frustration of having men only listen to other men whilst dismissing or outright ignoring women.” Ouch, but also – yes, exactly.

Another highly-upvoted response pointed out that this probably wasn’t an isolated incident: “I’m willing to bet this isn’t the first time he’s done something like this.” Double ouch, because that observation hits way too close to home for too many people.

Now, here’s where the story takes a surprisingly mature turn. Instead of letting this fester into a relationship-ending argument, our protagonist decided to communicate. She explained why his reaction had hurt her so much.

His response? He claimed that the way she had described the show and the clips she’d shown were “very different” from how his cousin had presented it. He insisted he hadn’t meant to blow her off.

Look, I want to give this guy the benefit of the doubt, but come on. How differently can you describe Gilmore Girls? It’s a show about a mother and daughter with rapid-fire dialogue living in a quirky small town. The math isn’t exactly complicated here.

The happy ending? They’re now watching it together. But the bigger question remains: why did it take another man’s recommendation for him to take his wife’s suggestion seriously?

This story perfectly encapsulates a frustration that goes way beyond entertainment preferences. How many times have women shared ideas in meetings only to be ignored, then watched those same ideas get praised when repeated by male colleagues? How often do women’s restaurant recommendations get dismissed until a male friend suggests the exact same place?

The pattern is exhaustingly familiar, and it’s happening in our most intimate relationships too. When your partner consistently dismisses your suggestions but jumps at identical recommendations from others, it sends a clear message about whose opinions they value.

Sure, they’re watching Gilmore Girls together now, and that’s great. But the real question is whether this husband truly understands why his behavior was problematic, or if he’s just trying to smooth things over.

What do you think – was she overreacting to a harmless coincidence, or does this reveal something deeper about respect in relationships? Have you ever experienced something similar? And more importantly, how would you have handled discovering your partner’s sudden interest in something they’d dismissed from you for years?

Post Stats:

• Original upvotes: 1,242
• Comments: 377
• Reading time: ~1 min

What do YOU think? Drop your take in the comments below!

Story originally shared on r/AmItheAsshole. Read the original discussion