Hear me out. Especially men. I want you to really really imagine the scenario and tell me if it can be just innocent thing not to worry about.

So we are together for almost a decade, most of it married. HAPPILY. We’ve grown so much together and built the perfect life and relationship for us. We trust each other and there are no icks or uncertainties between us when we talk to our opposite sex friends.

He had a very big crush on a girl from his high school for long 3 years. He eventually confessed then and received a rejection as the girl told him she doesn’t feel the same and she most probably likes girls more(still no certainty). He continued to be friends with her after rejection and then after school they stopped talking.

ALL OF A SUDDEN, my husband wakes up today and says he saw her in his dream after 15 years and immediately wanted to find her on social media to see what is she doing with her life and what she has become. He finds her and texts her – just casual – hi, how are you, just was thinking about high school and wanted to search for schoolmates here, etc,etc. Then “let’s meet and catch up sometimes this week”.

And he tells me about this only several hours later in the car, when he is back from out of town. He says “don’t freak out, here is the deal, I feel nothing about her now and I’m gonna meet her just to catch up – I want to know what you think about it”. I initially was shocked, then slowly was coming into terms with that when he says “you trust me right? I gave too much to build all this with you and I really value it to lose it because of something like this. So it’s just a catch up meeting, and 1)IF I REALIZE I FEEL SOMETHING, I WILL IMMEDIATELY STOP ANY COMMUNICATION AFTER THAT.

On the other hand, 2) IF I REALIZE SHE IS A GREAT PERSON, AND I DON’t FEEL ANYTHING ABOUT HER, I MAY STAY FRIENDS WITH HER BECAUSE I ALSO WANT A NEW PERSON TO TALK TO, LIKE YOU HAVE ALL THESE GUYS YOU TALK TO”.

Just to mention – every guy I generally talk to(not daily basis) is either his friend, my married coworkers or just old friends from former job or college who I NEVER HAD CRUSH ON OR HAD BEEN PURSUED BY.

I eventually told him that it’s okay to meet once and as I know her(I got acquainted with her 15 years ago, she’s a sweet girl) and she knows me, he can tell that we are happily married so that there’s no possibility that the girl thinks it’s a date or smth.

BUT AS i went to sleep, I started analyze and overthink everything.

I realized I would think a hundred times before writing to my former crush, let alone ask him to meet me.

I realized I would be okay if it was ANY OTHER GIRL, including ones that had crush on HIM, but not a person that he was in love with for a long 3 years and was telling me about with sparkles in his eyes when we were young and just friends.

I couldn’t sleep whole night, imagining ALL THAT COULD GO WRONG FROM THAT ONE MEETUP and breanching realities.

My afterthought that stayed was “WHY WOULD HE WANNA STIR THINGS UP WHEN THEY ARE THE MOST QUIET, EVEN IF HE DOESN’t have any feelings now”. It’s possible that the spark is reignited right? WHY?

I told him my thoughts in the morning after a completely sleepless night, HE GOT IMMEDIATELY SO MAD, only for that I could not sleep because of such a tiny irrelevant matter, that I sacrifice my health for things that didn’t happen yet and wouldn’t happen.

He started yelling that I don’t trust him, and that my overthinking is a big problem and I should not decide who he wants to meet and text. I said I should when it affects me and relationship, he said that if so, he will from now on refuse to let me meet any of my guy friends to show me how controlling my behavior feels. On my remark that I HAD NOT BEEN IN DEEP LOVE FOR 3 years with ANY of them, he said “jesus, it was 15 fucking years agooooo!!!”

Anyway, we had a big fight with tears and all, his last remark was “you became the woman I was happy you weren’t(in terms of sick jealousy)”. That hurt deeply. And added “this topic is closed, I won’t text her anymore and not meet her, as you wish”.

The thing is, if not for such things like telling me about his plans to stay connected with her, refusing to show me what they texted initally(and later showed) and even changing his 5 year old cringy username to a normal thing before writing her to “make an impression”, I would agree with the meetup and not have a second thought about it until later. But he behaved like an excited 15 year old with those actions. But I also think I really overdid my imagination.

Men, is it possible that this is an innocent thing and he is right? Is it possible that this will not lead to anything worse? If I set clear boundaries vs if I let him be – what could be the outcome? It surely feels like midlife crisis – like he wants to check if she will want him now – as he got better, fitter and good looking.

Idk, I’m confused. Help me.