The Original Post
So I recently got an awesome new deep fryer and was very excited to test out my skills. I decided to make fried chicken tenders and really do it right.
I did all the prep, seasoned the batter, cut the chicken. I’m currently staying at my parents house for the holidays though, so I didn’t know where anything was. No big deal I figured flour is flour, right?
I searched around the pantry, found something that looked like flour, and started coating the chicken. Immediately things felt… off. The coating was getting all gloopy and weird, and when I dropped the tenders into the fryer there was this strange solidified, granulated stuff forming in the oil. But I was already committed.
My parents came into the kitchen and told me I needed to dip the chicken in egg then flour, which explained why nothing was sticking properly. I was like ohhh okay that makes sense and kept going anyway.
I ate the chicken. I was trying to make it spicy, but somehow it was not spicy at all instead it was weirdly sweet. Still kind of good not what I was going for, but edible. I just felt bad because I tried really hard and it wasn’t turning out right.
Fast forward a few hours later, my sister comes home. I overhear her ask my parents “Did they use powdered sugar instead of flour?”
My stomach dropped. I immediately knew. Nothing in the pantry was labeled, but still I absolutely should’ve noticed. I think I was just so excited about the chicken that my brain shut off completely.
So yeah I deep-fried chicken tenders in powdered sugar.
I’m trying again tomorrow with actual flour. Hopefully this time I make food and not dessert.
TLDR: tried to make fried chicken at my parents house, couldn’t find flour, accidentally used powdered sugar, chicken was sweet, found out hours later I made candied chicken tenders.
What Reddit Said
Redditors found this kitchen disaster absolutely hilarious and relatable. Many users shared their own similar cooking mishaps involving mislabeled containers. The top comment perfectly captured everyone’s reaction: “Got to the bottom of the second paragraph and said, ‘oh no.'”
However, the story also sparked practical advice from experienced cooks. Several users emphasized the importance of properly labeling kitchen containers. Moreover, many shared their own tales of confusing powdered sugar with flour, proving this mistake is more common than expected.
The Verdict
The overwhelming consensus: this powdered sugar fried chicken mishap was a harmless but hilarious cooking fail. Reddit users were sympathetic and entertained rather than critical. In fact, this story became a perfect example of cooking disasters that turn into memorable family stories rather than actual problems.
Original post from r/tifu (1,054 upvotes, 122 comments)