Previous Owner Demands House Access After Selling Property

A 25-year-old woman refused to let the previous owner demands house access after she sold the property years earlier. The former owner then banged on the door with neighbors for over an hour.

Previous Owner Demands House Access: The Backstory

The house was built by a carpenter who lived there with his wife and daughter since 1976. However, the wife died in 2014 and the daughter moved away in 2015.

The carpenter lived alone until he passed away in 2020. Subsequently, his daughter returned to sell the house to the current family.

Meanwhile, the new owners found expensive carpentry tools, cooking supplies, and family photos left behind. Therefore, they spent two years trying to contact the daughter to return these items.

The Previous Owner Access Incident

In 2022, the daughter finally answered their calls. However, she screamed at the mother and said she didn’t want any of her parents’ belongings.

Consequently, the family sold the tools and cooking supplies. Furthermore, they gave the family photos to the neighbor who knew the original owner.

Last week, the daughter appeared at the neighbor’s fence. Initially, she thanked them for giving away the photos.

Nevertheless, when she learned about the sold items, she lost her mind. Moreover, she called the current owner a liar and demanded to see inside the house.

The homeowner refused because of the daughter’s hostile behavior. As a result, both the daughter and neighbor banged on the front door for over an hour.

What Reddit Said

Most people said the homeowner was completely justified in refusing entry. In fact, many praised her for not letting an aggressive person into her home.

Some pointed out that the family had tried for years to return the belongings. Therefore, the daughter had no right to complain about items being sold.

A few suggested showing the neighbors the text messages and emails as proof. However, others said the neighbors’ opinions didn’t matter since the homeowner did nothing wrong.

Many commenters noted that letting her inside would have ended badly. Furthermore, they predicted she would have caused damage or started more fights.

The Verdict

Overall verdict: OP is Not the Asshole. The previous owner demands house access situation shows why you shouldn’t let hostile people into your home, regardless of their history with the property.

For more dramatic property disputes, check out our AITA stories and family drama categories.

From r/AmItheAsshole (2,077 upvotes)