Uncle Criticizes Parenting Then Gets Mad When Teen Fights…
The Original Post
Backstory: my mom died when I (14f) was little. She had been sick for a while and before she died she set everything up so I would go to her best friend, Katie. My uncle, Nick, fought for custody of me after my mom died because he thought I should be with family. Katie has custody of me and adopted me but I spend one weekend a month with Nick and his family, although lately itās been a little less because of competitions. The visits to Nicks house arenāt court ordered Katie just wants me to have a connection with my bio family
Nick and Katie are very different parents. Katie and her husband are both doctors. Nick is a cop and his wife is a preschool teacher.
Iāve been in private school my entire life and my school is 1-2 years ahead of the local public schools, which are also some of the best in the area and are ahead of the public schools in other areas. Nick and his wife homeschool their kids (10, 14, 16), mostly for political reasons.
I do competitive cheerleading through my school and I do competitive dance through a studio. I also play piano I used to do clarinet but I just quit to have more time for cheer. Nicks kids go to church youth group and youth choir and donāt do any other activities. Katie also makes me earn my allowance. I have to work and sheāll match whatever I make at the end of the month and Nick just gives his kids money whenever.
I was at Nicks house last weekend and he was doing his usual thing where he talks shit about Katie and her parenting and how I never have free time (not true btw) because Iām always doing homework or at dance or cheer or working and how his kids actually get to be kids because they only do 2-3 hours of school a day and donāt have to worry about competitions or maintaining a 3.0 GPA (my school requires you to have a 3.0 for any extracurriculars and if Iām not allowed to participate in school activities Iām not allowed to participate in after school activities). He said something like āwouldnāt it be nice to slow down and get to be a kid like his kids doā.
I told him I like my life the way it is and I wouldnāt want to be like his kids. Iām going to start dual enrollment college classes next year and I donāt know if his kids are even gonna be able to go to college considering my 10 year old cousin still canāt multiply single digit numbers and my 14 year old cousin is technically a grade above me but she canāt solve simple linear equations. Plus they donāt have any hobbies. Every time I come over we just go to the mall and look around and watch movies at their house and eat a lot of fast food.
He got pissed because I have no right to criticize his parenting and insult his kids so he called Katie and told her to pick me up early because Iām a āspoiled entitled brat that thinks Iām better than themā. Katie thinks I shouldāve just smiled and nodded and that I went a little too far. Weāve decided itāll be best if I donāt go to their house for a while but Iām starting to feel bad because I did kinda call my cousins stupid.
What Reddit Said
Redditors overwhelmingly supported the teenager in this situation. Most pointed out the obvious hypocrisy: Uncle Nick dishes out criticism constantly but can’t handle receiving it. The top comment highlighted how he regularly insults both OP and Katie’s parenting choices.
However, commenters also noted that OP didn’t actually call her cousins stupid. Instead, she gave specific examples of their academic struggles. Many felt the uncle should thank her for the honest feedback rather than throwing a tantrum.
The Verdict
The overwhelming consensus: OP is Not the Asshole (NTA). This situation perfectly illustrates what happens when someone who constantly criticizes others gets a taste of their own medicine. Uncle Nick created this conflict by repeatedly badmouthing Katie’s parenting during visits. Moreover, OP simply stated facts about her cousins’ education rather than making personal attacks. This is a clear case of family conflict where the adult couldn’t handle honest feedback about his parenting choices.
Original post from r/AmItheAsshole (1,353 upvotes, 250 comments)