Wife’s “Crush” on Personal Trainer Was Actually Cheating
The Original Post
Original: https://www.reddit.com/r/relationship\_advice/s/MzifYDGS2h
So I spoke to my wife the night after my original post.
I said she needs to leave her personal trainer, Quit that gym, and we need to start going to couples counselling. She wasnāt happy and started arguing saying itās only a crush and itāll pass and sheās making good progress and then started to frame it as me not caring about her health. Once she realised I wasnāt budging she started trying to bargain with me and saying what if she stopped seeing the personal trainer could she still go to the gym and if she started having sex with me again we donāt need couples counselling.
I lost my temper at this point I admit and shouted āenough! I want to know everything! Tell me everything youāve done! I want to read your messages with him! I want to see these outfits you are wearing! I need to know everything now!ā She said fine and stormed off upstairs. She came back down wearing an outfit that was a bit much to be fair for the gym in a cold country but I didnāt say anything and asked to see her phone. She said she deleted the messages. When I asked why she was honest and said she sent him a topless selfie on Christmas Day while I was downstairs cooking the dinner for her bloody family! She then said that while sheās confessing she also kissed another man on a night out in the first year of our relationship. I already knew this because her friend who fancied me at the time told me about it.
I asked her why him and not me. Whatās he got that I havenāt. She said nothing and it was more about the situation than him. She said sheās starting to feel regret and like she missed out on her youth. She had a boyfriend from school to her early 20s, was single for a year and then met me. She said sheās started to regret not having more fun and sheās starting to enjoy attention from other men more and more especially younger men. When she was telling me originally she said a couple of times āIām not planning on doing anything itās just a fantasy, unless you want me to do somethingā with a nervous laughter and at the time it felt a bit like she wanted to do something but was trying to frame it as my idea but I never really clicked properly. I asked her if when she told me she was expecting me to give her permission and she said she genuinely thought because I donāt get jealous Iād be ok with it
I still feel like I wasnāt being given everything though. The outfit and the kiss confession felt like distractions and something was missing. Even telling me about all this in the first place felt a bit like ah was trying to get her story in before someone else told me. I said Iām going for a drive and then went to the gym to speak to her personal trainer. I approached him and said Iām not here for trouble I understand my wife has been harassing you. He wasnāt happy being approached this way which I get but he asked me who my wife was and when I told him he said he knew something like this was going to happen. He told me that he hadnāt trained her since Christmas as he let her go after she had been sending pictures (plural not just the one she told me about). He said since then she had kept messaging but he ignored her. He let me read the messages and she had sent 12 pictures over a three month period. One was fully naked and when he told her not to send them she said she was just showing her progress. The worst part though was she was messaging him stuff like āweāve had another argument could really do with a session to burn off some angerā and āheās out drinking with his friends again ignoring me, Iām so lonelyā neither of which are true and then she told him mid December that she had kicked me out and we were divorcing! With the Christmas Day picture she even said āfirst Christmas aloneā and just last week she messaged him saying I was already seeing someone else!
I thanked him and asked him to send me them and went home. When I got home she was already gone and just wrote me a note saying sorry. Sheās at her friendās house and weāve been texting a bit the last couple of days and have a marriage counsellor booked for next week but I think itās done. Iām not even that bothered about the pictures or the flirting or the outfit. The lying about me and our marital status. I donāt drink and we hadnāt argued in years. Iām downstairs entertaining her family while sheās sending nudes (sheās never sent me one) and telling him sheās alone.
Iām working all this weekend to try and keep my mind busy. Sorry if I donāt reply quick enough and thank you to everyone who took the time to read and reply to my last post.
TLDR: it was a lot worse than she originally let on.
What Reddit Said
Reddit users were unanimous in their judgment. This wasn’t a harmless crush but active cheating behavior. Most commenters praised the husband for handling the situation maturely. However, they were furious about the wife’s deception and manipulation.
Moreover, Redditors had surprising respect for the personal trainer. Many pointed out he acted professionally by cutting off contact and ignoring her advances. In fact, several users noted that if he had been willing, the wife would have definitely cheated physically.
The Verdict
The overwhelming consensus: the marriage is over, and rightfully so. This wife crush personal trainer situation revealed systematic lying and emotional manipulation. Reddit saw this as a clear case of cheating and infidelity disguised as innocent attraction. The husband deserves better than someone who sends nudes to other men while cooking dinner for her family downstairs.
Original post from r/relationship_advice (2,564 upvotes, 552 comments)